<< Click to Display Table of Contents >> Navigation:  Forms and Sets > Form 4 > Variations > Specific Variations > Protecting Fans - Initial Parry - Orientation

This variation is generally considered destructive.

 

The initial parry orientation of the technique Protecting Fans is changed. This variation is accomplished by altering the alignment of the initial parry from horizontal (e.g. fingers pointing forward) to vertical (e.g. fingers pointing upward). This variation basically comes down to an argument of an emphasis on realism (stylized) over theme (idealized).

 

Rationale For

The rationale for this variation is to be more realistic in execution (i.e. how one would actually parry a potential attack). Execution with a vertical orientation provides more Margin for Error than the horizontal orientation, which also adds to the general appearance of being more realistic and practical from the observer's perspective.

 

Rationale Against

The rationale against this variation is that it eliminates both inter-form and intra-form relationships. In this specific case, a horizontal orientation provides not only relationships within this form, but also between previous and future forms. Using the less realistic orientation allows for better visualization of these relationships (from both an observer's and the practitioner's perspective), and for the practitioner to more easily understand / be constantly reminded of these relationships between forms.